Archive of record, surveillance layer, or both
Firms that shortlist Smarsh vs Global Relay are usually asking two questions at once and getting a muddled answer until they split them. First: which system is the archive of record, where every regulated communication sits, tamper-evident, for the retention period? Second: which system captures and analyzes the channels your people actually use, from Teams and Zoom to WhatsApp, WeChat and recorded voice?
Smarsh and Global Relay both try to answer both questions in one platform. Theta Lake started with the second. It built its business on capturing and analyzing collaboration tools, especially video meetings, screen shares and in-meeting chat, and it's often deployed in front of a separate archive. It does offer compliant storage of its own, so some firms use it as the archive. In many banks and broker-dealers, though, it runs alongside Smarsh, Global Relay or another archive.
A fair comparison, then, isn't a three-way race for one contract. It looks more like this:
- Smarsh: a broad portfolio covering capture, archive tiers for small and large firms, conduct surveillance and eDiscovery, built partly through acquisitions.
- Global Relay: an integrated archive, surveillance and eDiscovery platform with a strong following among banks and capital-markets firms.
- Theta Lake: a specialist in collaboration and video compliance, with risk detection inside meetings. It feeds archives or provides its own storage.
Vendors in this market change hands and product names often. Check each vendor's current ownership, product lines and roadmap before you sign, because support quality can shift after an acquisition.
Looking to streamline vendor RFP selection?
Access pre-negotiated tier discounts through our independent institutional network.
Channel capture coverage: where the three actually differ
Every vendor claims to cover dozens of channels. Ask how each channel is captured, because the method decides fidelity, latency and what breaks when the source platform changes its API.
There are four broad methods. API or journaling connectors pull from platforms like Microsoft 365, Bloomberg and Slack. Mobile capture uses a managed app, a carrier-level service, or a containerized messaging client. Voice capture runs through telephony integrations or recording platforms. Native platform integrations, such as the compliance recording frameworks in Zoom and Teams, hand off full meeting content.
| Capability | Smarsh | Global Relay | Theta Lake |
|---|---|---|---|
| Email, Microsoft 365, Google Workspace | Core strength, wide connector library | Core strength | Not its focus; usually left to the archive |
| Teams, Zoom, Webex, Slack chat | Supported through connectors | Supported through connectors | Core strength, including in-meeting chat and file shares |
| Video, screen share, whiteboard content | Typically recordings and transcripts | Typically recordings and transcripts | Deepest coverage; analyzes what was shown and said |
| WhatsApp, WeChat, SMS, iMessage | Broad mobile capture options | Mobile capture plus its own messaging app | Some channels; often paired with a mobile capture partner |
| Bloomberg, ICE and trading chat | Supported | Strong; a long-standing focus | Limited relative to the others |
| Voice and turret recording | Supported, often through partners | Supported | Meeting audio, plus some voice platforms |
Treat this table as a starting point, not a feature matrix you can sign against. Ask each vendor for its current connector list. For every channel you care about, ask whether the connector is built in-house or by a partner, and whose SLA covers a capture gap when a partner connector fails. Gaps matter more than coverage counts. Regulators have fined firms for missing off-channel messages, and a lost week of WhatsApp traffic is exactly that exposure.
Red flag: a vendor that can't show you, in a live demo, how a deleted or edited message appears in the archive for a given channel. Edits and deletions are where capture methods differ most.
Tamper-proof storage against record-keeping rules in several regions
All three vendors market storage that meets major record-keeping regimes. Confirm which regime, under which configuration, and whether there's independent evidence. For US broker-dealers, that usually means a third-party assessment of the storage against SEC Rule 17a-4(f). Ask for the current assessment letter, not a marketing summary.
| Regime | What it generally requires | What to ask the vendor |
|---|---|---|
| SEC Rule 17a-4 and FINRA recordkeeping rules (US broker-dealers) | Electronic records kept in non-rewriteable, non-erasable (WORM) form or under the audit-trail alternative added in recent amendments; retention generally several years depending on record type; prompt production to regulators | Which option do you support? Can you show the independent assessment? Who acts as designated third party or supports our designated executive officer? |
| MiFID II (EU) | Recording of telephone conversations and electronic communications relating to transactions; retention generally around five years, longer if the competent authority requests it; records protected from alteration | Can retention be set per jurisdiction and per record type? Is the original record preserved alongside any edits? |
| FCA rules (UK) | Similar recording obligations under the UK regime; generally around five years, extendable | Can UK and EU records be stored separately if our entities need it? |
| MAS (Singapore) | Record-keeping under the securities regulatory framework, plus MAS expectations on outsourcing and technology risk management | Can you support our outsourcing and audit-access obligations? Where are the records hosted? |
Other regions add their own wrinkles. Hong Kong's SFC sets conditions for licensed firms that keep regulatory records with an external electronic storage provider, including regulator access. Regulators in the UAE, Saudi Arabia, India and Australia each have record-keeping and outsourcing expectations that can decide where data may sit. Retention periods and storage conditions vary by license type, so have compliance counsel map each legal entity's obligations before you configure retention. Don't rely on vendor defaults.
On architecture, Global Relay has long promoted its own purpose-built infrastructure. Smarsh has used a mix of its own environments and public cloud, depending on the product tier. Theta Lake is cloud-native. Confirm each current setup with the vendor. None of these is better in principle. What matters is the documented immutability control, the independent assessment, and how legal holds override retention-based deletion.
Surveillance depth and eDiscovery for financial services
Capture and storage keep you compliant on paper. Surveillance is where you find misconduct, and where most of the long-term cost and analyst workload sits.
Smarsh
Smarsh's conduct surveillance combines natural-language models, built on technology from its Digital Reasoning acquisition, with traditional lexicon-based policies. It suits larger firms that want to tune behavioral models across email, chat and voice transcripts and will staff a team to do it. Smaller firms often stay on the lexicon-and-sampling features of a lower-tier archive. For an RIA or small broker-dealer's supervisory review, that's usually enough.
Global Relay
Global Relay offers surveillance, review and eDiscovery in the same platform as its archive. That removes data movement and gives you one audit trail from capture through review to production. It has been adding machine-learning risk scoring on top of lexicons. Capital-markets buyers tend to favor its trader-chat and multi-channel review workflows.
Theta Lake
Theta Lake's depth is in content the others handle less thoroughly: what appeared on a shared screen, a document shown in a video call, a risky phrase spoken in a client webinar, an unapproved file shared in meeting chat. If advisors run client reviews over Zoom or Teams, this is the gap it fills. It isn't designed to be your firm-wide trade surveillance or market-abuse platform. Firms with market-abuse obligations under MAR or similar regimes usually keep a dedicated surveillance tool as well.
eDiscovery
The test is speed to production under a regulatory request. Run a timed scenario during the proof of concept: have each vendor find every communication involving three named custodians over a 90-day window across email, Teams and WhatsApp, apply a legal hold, and export in a load-file format your outside counsel can use. Smarsh and Global Relay both have mature case management. With Theta Lake you'll often run discovery from the downstream archive, so check that its metadata survives the handoff.
Red flag: high false-positive rates that the vendor answers with "you can tune it." Ask how many alerts per 100 users per month a firm of your profile typically sees after tuning, and how many analyst hours that takes.
Looking to streamline vendor RFP selection?
Access pre-negotiated tier discounts through our independent institutional network.
Data residency: where your records actually live
For global firms, data residency often decides the shortlist before features do. GDPR, the UK GDPR, India's Digital Personal Data Protection Act, Gulf data-protection laws, and banking secrecy or outsourcing rules in places like Switzerland, Singapore and Hong Kong all affect where communications data can be stored and who can access it.
All three vendors offer hosting in more than one region, and Theta Lake, being cloud-native, can usually deploy wherever its cloud providers operate. The specifics change. Get the current list of hosting locations in writing and put it in the contract.
These questions separate real residency from a marketing claim:
- Are primary storage, backups and disaster-recovery copies all in the stated region?
- Where do surveillance models run, and do transcripts or extracted text leave the region for processing?
- Where are support engineers located, and can they access customer data from outside the region? Under what approval controls?
- Can one tenant hold separate regional stores for different legal entities, with unified search for authorized global users?
- In a layered Theta Lake setup, where does content sit between capture and delivery to the downstream archive, and for how long?
That last question catches many firms out. If Theta Lake captures a Teams meeting in one region and delivers it to an archive in another, you have two residency footprints to document, not one.
Pricing, cost drivers and contract red flags
None of the three publishes full enterprise pricing, and quotes vary widely by volume, term and bundle. The ranges below are typical 2026 market ranges per user per month. They vary by contract and region, so confirm with each vendor.
| Component | Typical range (USD per user per month) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Email and Microsoft 365 archive | $3 to $12 | Lower end for small firms on standard tiers |
| Multi-channel archive (chat, collaboration, social) | $8 to $25 | Often priced per connector or channel bundle |
| Mobile capture (WhatsApp, SMS, WeChat) | $10 to $30 additional | Carrier-based options can carry per-line fees |
| Video and collaboration compliance (Theta Lake-style) | $15 to $40 | Depends on platforms covered and analysis depth |
| Advanced conduct surveillance | $15 to $50+ | Enterprise deals may be priced by volume instead |
Say a hypothetical 300-person wealth manager needs email, Teams, Zoom video and WhatsApp capture, plus basic surveillance. At mid-range pricing that could land around $35 to $70 per user per month across components, or roughly $125,000 to $250,000 a year before implementation. Your quote could fall well outside that.
The cost drivers that move the number most:
- Data migration from a legacy archive. Moving ten years of email with chain-of-custody evidence can cost more than the first year's subscription. Get a fixed quote.
- Storage overages for video. Meeting recordings grow storage fast, and some contracts price storage beyond a per-user allowance.
- Exit and export fees. Ask what it costs to export everything in a usable format if you leave. It's a frequent contract surprise.
- Professional services for surveillance tuning, often sold as an ongoing retainer.
- Minimum seat commitments on multi-year terms that outlast a restructuring.
If you layer Theta Lake on top of an archive, check for duplicate charges, where you pay both vendors to store the same meeting content.
Verdict by firm size and type
There's no single winner in Smarsh vs Global Relay, and Theta Lake changes the question instead of answering it. Here's how we'd frame the decision for different buyers.
Small RIAs, independent wealth managers and small broker-dealers (under roughly 100 users). Pick one archive and keep it simple. Both Smarsh's lower-tier archive and Global Relay's standard archive cover email, common chat and mobile capture with the storage evidence regulators expect. Choose on mobile capture fit and support responsiveness during the trial. Add Theta Lake only if video client meetings are central to how advisors work.
Mid-sized wealth managers, asset managers and regional banks (roughly 100 to 2,000 users). This is where the layered model earns its cost. If advisors and relationship managers hold regular client meetings on Zoom or Teams, Theta Lake in front of a Smarsh or Global Relay archive gives deeper meeting-risk coverage than either archive alone. If video is minor, a single platform with integrated surveillance cuts integration work and keeps one audit trail.
Global banks and capital-markets firms. Global Relay is usually the better fit when trader chat, voice and one integrated archive-surveillance-eDiscovery workflow matter most. Smarsh is the stronger option if you want to invest in tuned behavioral models across very large volumes. Either way, expect to add a specialist like Theta Lake for collaboration content and a dedicated trade surveillance tool for market abuse. Data residency across entities will likely decide the contract more than features.
Fintechs and payment firms under lighter communications-recording rules. Start with your actual obligations, which may come down to record retention and eDiscovery rather than full surveillance. A multi-channel archive with good search is often enough. Revisit surveillance when you add a regulated investment or brokerage license.
Next step: list your top five channels by message volume and your legal entities by jurisdiction. Then run a 30-day proof of concept with two vendors on real data, including the timed eDiscovery test and a deleted-message test on mobile. The vendor that produces complete, correctly retained records for every channel, with residency documented in the contract, gets the deal.